Preface. 1. The Employment Relationship and the Field of Industrial Relations: Paul Edwards. 2. The Historical Evolution of British Industrial Relations: Richard Hyman. 3. The Labour Market: History, Structure and Prospects: Peter Nolan and Gary Slater. 4. Foreign Multinationals and Industrial Relations Innovation in Britain: Anthony Ferner. 5. The State: Economic Management and Incomes Policy: Colin Crouch. 6. Labour Law and Industrial Relations: a New Settlement? Linda Dickens and Mark Hall. 7. Management: Systems, Structures and Strategy: Keith Sisson and Paul Marginson. 8. The Management of Pay as the Influence of Collective Bargaining Diminishes: William Brown, Paul Marginson and Janet Walsh. 9. Trade Union Organization: Jeremy Waddington. 10. Employee Representation: Shop Stewards and the New Legal Framework: Michael Terry. 11. Industrial Relations in the Public Sector: Stephen Bach and David Winchester. 12. Individualism and Collectivism in Industrial Relations: Ian Kessler and John Purcell. 13. New Forms of Work Organization: Still Limited, Still Controlled, but Still Welcome? John F. Geary. 14. Managing Without Unions: the Sources and Limitations of Individualism: Trevor Colling. 15. Training: Ewart Keep and Helen Rainbird. 16. The Industrial Relations of a Diverse Workforce: Sonia Liff. 17. Low Pay and the National Minimum Wage: Jill Rubery and Paul Edwards. 18. Employment Relations in Small Firms: Richard Scase. 19. Industrial Relations, Human Resource Management and Performance: Peter Nolan and Kathy O'Donnell. Index.
This book has both empirical and theoretical goals. The primary empirical goal is to examine the evolution of industrial relations in Western Europe from the end of the 1970s up to the present. Its purpose is to evaluate the extent to which liberalization has taken hold of European industrial relations and institutions through five detailed, chapter-length studies, each focusing on a different country and including quantitative analysis. The book offers a comprehensive description and analysis of what has happened to the institutions that regulate the labor market, as well as the relations between employers, unions, and states in Western Europe since the collapse of the long postwar boom. The primary theoretical goal of this book is to provide a critical examination of some of the central claims of comparative political economy, particularly those involving the role and resilience of national institutions in regulating and managing capitalist political economies. Read more at http://www.cambridge.org/de/academic/subjects/politics-international-relations/comparative-politics/trajectories-neoliberal-transformation-european-industrial-relations-1970s#v0YMDsbtzXTidrfP.99This book has both empirical and theoretical goals. The primary empirical goal is to examine the evolution of industrial relations in Western Europe from the end of the 1970s up to the present. Its purpose is to evaluate the extent to which liberalization has taken hold of European industrial relations and institutions through five detailed, chapter-length studies, each focusing on a different country and including quantitative analysis. The book offers a comprehensive description and analysis of what has happened to the institutions that regulate the labor market, as well as the relations between employers, unions, and states in Western Europe since the collapse of the long postwar boom. The primary theoretical goal of this book is to provide a critical examination of some of the central claims of comparative political economy, particularly those involving the role and resilience of national institutions in regulating and managing capitalist political economies.
The paper assesses current trajectories of change in the German system of industrial relations by analysing the co‐determination and collective bargaining systems. It argues that two parallel developments undermine the institutional stability of the German model. First, the institutional base of the German industrial relations system, which has served as the pre‐condition of its past success, has been shrinking during the last two decades. This is due to a decline in coverage by the two major industrial relations institutions: the works council system and wage agreements. Today fewer than 15 per cent of German plants are covered by both a valid collective agreement and a works council. Second, increasing decentralization pressures within collective bargaining tend to undermine the division of labour between co‐determination and collective bargaining. The dynamics of an institutional erosion of the German industrial relations institutions and the decentralization of collective bargaining disturbs the fine‐tuning of the mediating process between macroeconomic steering capacity and co‐operative workplace industrial relations. This tendency has been aggravated by the effects of German unification. The current institutional developments of the German industrial relations system leave serious doubts about the future of a successful model of co‐operative modernization.
List of Figures. List of Tables. Contributors. Foreword. Preface. 1. Introduction: Economic Restructuring, Market Liberalism and the Future of National Industrial Relations Systems: Richard Hyman (University of Warwick). 2. The Structure of Transnational Capital in Europe: The Emerging Euro--Company and its Implications for Industrial Relations: Paul Marginson (University of Warwick) Keith Sisson (University of Warwick). 3. The State as Employer: Anthony Ferner (University of Warwick). 4. European Trade Unions: The Transition Years: Jelle Visser (University of Amsterdam). 5. Changing Trade Union Identities and Strategies: Richard Hyman (University of Warwick). 6. Does Feminization Mean a Flexible Labour Force?: Jill Rubery (Manchester School of Management, UMIST) and Colette Fagan (Manchester School of Management, UMIST). 7. Industrial Order and the Transformation of Industrial Relations: Britain, Germany and France Compared: Christel Lane (St. Johns College, Cambridge). 8. Beyond Corporatism: The Impact of Company Strategy: Colin Crouch (Trinity College, Oxford). 9. Workplace Unionism: Redefining Structures and Objectives: Michael Terry (University of Warwick). 10. Strikes and Industrial Conflict: Peace In Europe?: P. K. Edwards (University of Warwick) and Richard Hyman (University of Warwick). 11. Industrial Relations and the Social Dimension of European Integration: Before and After Maastricht: Mark Hall (University of Warwick). 12. Tripartism in Eastern Europe: Lajos Hethy (Institute of Labour Research, Budapest). 13. The Changing Contours of Trade Unionism in Easter Europe and the CIS: Denis MacShane (International Metalworkers Federation, Geneva and European Policy Institute). 14. Post--Communism and the Emergence of Industrial Relations in the Workplace: Simon Clarke (University of Warwick) and Peter Fairbrother (University of Warwick). Index.
The labour relationship - a conceptual analysis industrial relations systems comparative industrial relations systems the South African industrial relations system in societal and historical context the legislative framework governing the employment relationship trade unions and employer organizations - theoretical basis South African trade unions and employers' organizations - the tripartite collective bargaining collective bargaining in South Africa labour relationships at the workplace basic principles of labour economics negotiation dispute settlement industrial democracy and workers' participation organizational change and organizational development industrial relations future.
This article presents a critique of the ‘methodological nationalism’ of traditional comparative industrial relations. It investigates nine different sectors across the 27 EU member states on the basis of seven empirical indicators. It is found that industrial relations vary across sectors as deeply as they do across countries, and that a cluster analysis of sectoral industrial relations produces very different results from one at national aggregate level. The concept of ‘national model’ of industrial relations, implying coherence and homogeneity within countries, and geographical typologies of industrial relations ‘types’, are therefore put in question. The article concludes by pointing at the theoretical and methodological implications of a focus on the sector as an important level of analysis.
Abstract European industrial relations are rapidly internationalizing; internationalization, however, is not necessarily de-nationalization. Even as European integration accelerates, national politics and industrial relations will remain the principal arenas for the social regulation of work and employment in Europe. The paper investigates the implications of European industrial relations developing into a multi-level system within which national regimes compete with each other in an integrated international market. In particular, it tries to outline the emerging new peace formula between business and labor in Europe, which is centered on the notion of joint competitiveness, and its consequences for social protection and the regulation of labor markets. Five examples are given for the continuing importance of national industrial relations in integrated Europe: the renewal of tripartite concertation at national level, especially under the pressure of the Maastricht criteria; the likely impact of European Monetary Union on national collective bargaining regimes; the practical consequences of the European Works Councils Directive of 1994; the experience with the Social Dialogue since the Maastricht Treaty; and the Posted Workers Directive, which is discussed as a possible paradigm of the future relationship between European and national social protection in Europe.
This study tests the “strategic choice” proposition that variation in workplace industrial relations policies and practices is related to differences in business strategy. A cluster analysis of data from a 1988–89 questionnaire examining workplace industrial relations and business strategies in U.S. steel minimills suggests that the industrial relations systems of these mills can be broadly categorized as emphasizing either cost reduction or employee commitment; similarly, the business strategies of the mills appear to stress either the manufacture of a few products in large quantities at the lowest possible cost, or more flexible manufacturing, with products marketed on some basis other than cost. Further investigation shows a significant association between the type of workplace industrial relations system and the business strategy choices in these mills.
Book synopsis: This original book is a wide-ranging, radical and highly innovative critique of the prevailing orthodoxies within industrial relations and human resource management. It covers: \n \ncentral problems in industrial relations \nthe mobilization theory of collective action \nthe growth of non-union workplaces and the prospects and desirability of a new labour-management social partnership \nan historical account of worker collectivism, organization and militancy and state or employer counter mobilization \na critique of postmodernism and accounts of the end of the labour movement \nContaining a detailed examination of the evolution of industrial relations, it argues that the area is often under-theorized and influenced by the policy agenda of the state or employers, and will prove informative reading for students of industrial relations.
This original book is a wide-ranging, radical and highly innovative critique of the prevailing orthodoxies within industrial relations and human resource management. It covers: central problems in industrial relations the mobilization theory of collective action the growth of non-union workplaces and the prospects and desirability of a new labour-management social partnership an historical account of worker collectivism, organization and militancy and state or employer counter mobilization a critique of postmodernism and accounts of the end of the labour movement Containing a detailed examination of the evolution of industrial relations, it argues that the area is often under-theorized and influenced by the policy agenda of the state or employers, and will prove informative reading for students of industrial relations.
This enlightening book provides the first systematic introduction to, and exploration of, the emerging system of industrial relations in China, and draws on the authors' extensive research and direct involvement in the developments taking place. The authors argue that there are both unifying and fragmenting elements to the ongoing development of industrial relations, but overall it is one in which the state continues to maintain a major, and direct, influence. Divisions between workers and managers may be escalating with increased open conflicts, but this book reveals that the picture is far more complex and contradictory than to assume that the solution is convergence with western style industrial relations systems. They conclude that industrial relations institutions and processes still act within a political context and with the guiding hand of the Chinese Communist party.
Over the past decade, several leading U.S. scholars have advanced a new industrial relations paradigm, according to which “high performance” work and human resource management (HRM) practices have replaced unions and collective bargaining as the innovative force in industrial relations. Although this model fundamentally challenges the traditional focus of the field of industrial relations in the United States, research on it has centered on the diffusion and performance effects of HRM innovations, with surprisingly little systematic reflection on either the underlying tenets of the new paradigm or its implications for the future of the field. Drawing on work of British and U.S. scholars, the authors identify critical aspects of the literature on this subject that deserve careful scrutiny, and suggest several criteria (such as industrial democracy) that need to be used in addition to measures of firm performance in evaluating the new paradigm.
This is an opportune time to renegotiate the boundaries between industrial relations theory and feminist analysis in Britain. Such a bargain would involve going beyond an agreement to add ‘women’s issues’ to the research agenda, to a recognition of the gendered character of employment relations and of work itself. The formal institutions involved, namely, management, trade unions and the state, cannot be treated as gender‐neutral. Further, the very way industrial relations scholars define what is ‘inside’ the industrial relations system and what is ‘outside’ reflects masculine priorities and privilege.
List of Contributors. Preface. Introduction: Towards European Industrial Relations?. 1. Great Britain: From Partial Collectivism to Neo--liberalism to Where?: Paul Edwards (University of Warwick), Mark Hall (University of Warwick), Richard Hyman (University of Warwick), Paul Marginson (University of Leeds), Keith Sisson (University of Warwick), Jeremy Waddington (University of Warwick), and David Winchester (University of Warwick). 2. Ireland: Corporation Revived: Ferdinand von Prondzynski (University of Hull). 3. Sweden: Restoring the Model?: Anders Kjellberg (University of Lund). 4. Norway: The Revival of Centralised Concertation: Jon Erik Dolvik and Torgeir Aarvaag Stokke (Both Institute for Applied Social Science, Oslo). 5. Denmark: A Less Regulated Model: Steen Scheuer (Copenhagen Business School). 6. Finland: Continuity and Modest Moves Towards Company--Level Corporatism: Kari Lilja (Helsinki School of Economics and Business Administration). 7. Germany: Facing New Challenges: Otto Jacobi (Laboratorium Europa), Berndt Keller (University of Konstanz), and Walther Muller--Jentsch (Ruhr University of Bochum). 8. Austria: Still the Country of Corporatism: Franz Traxler (University of Vienna). 9. Switzerland: Still as Smooth as Clockwork?: Robert Flunder and Beat Hotz--Hart (Both University of Zurich). 10. The Netherlands: The Return of Responsive Corporatism: Jelle Visser (University of Amsterdam and Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies, Cologne). 11. Belgium: The Great Transformation: Jacques Vilrokx and Jim Van Leemput (Both Vrije Universiteit Brussel). 12. Luxembourg: A Small Success Story: Gary Tunsch (Ministry of Labour and National Conciliation Office, Luxembourg). 13. France: The Limits of Reform: Janine Goetschy (Universite de Paris--Nanterre). 14. Portugal: Industrial Relations under Democracy: Jose Barreto (University of Lisbon) and Reinhard Naumann (freelance researcher). 15. Spain: Regulating Employment and Social Fragmentation: Miguel Martinez Lucio (University of Leeds). 16. Italy: The Dual Character of Industrial Relations: Ida Regalia (University of Turin) and Marino Regini (University of Milan). 17. Greece: The Maturing of the System: Nicos Kritsantonis. Index.
Abstract For more than a century of development, the industrial relations systems of Western European countries grew in very diverse and changing ways. The forms they adopted can be mapped against a set of basic types, and this study moves between historical detail and theoretical typology in order to capture the complexity of that mapping. The book traces the development of trade unions, organized employers, the state's role, and patterns of industrial conflict in 15 countries. It concludes by linking contemporary industrial relations systems to a longue durŽe of relations between states and societies reaching back to the Reformation.
Part 1: The Factories 1. Four Factories: A First Look 2. The Workers: Who They Are, How They Are Recruited and Trained 3. Wages 4. Unions: Membership and Organization 5. Industrial Relations: Mainly England 6. Industrial Relations: Mainly Japan 7. Industrial Relations: Summary 8. The Enterprise as Community 9. Authority, Function and Status 10. Two Employment Systems 11. Some Implications Part 2: Convergence? 12. The 'Japanese Employment System' and Recent Trends of Change 13. Britain Catching Up? Part Three: The Past and the Future 14. The Origins of the Japanese Employment System 15. Late Development Appendix: The Survey Index.
Contributors Series Editors' Foreword Preface Introduction 1. Great Britain: Still Muddling Through?: Paul Edwards, Mark Hall, Richard Hyman, Paul Marginson, Keith Sisson, Jeremy Waddington, David Winchester 2. Ireland: Between Centralism and the Market: Ferdinand von Prondzynski 3. Sweden: Can the Model Survive?: Anders Kjellberg 4. Norway: The 'Norwegian Model' in Transition: Jon Erik Dolvik and Dag Stokland 5. Denmark: Return to Decentralization: Steen Scheuer 6. Finland: No Longer the Nordic Exception: Kari Kilja 7. Germany: Co-determining the Future: Otti Jacobi, Berndt Keller, Walther Muller-Jentsch 8. Austria: Still the Country of Corporatism: Franz Traxler 9. Switzerland: Still as Smooth as Clockwork?: Beat Hotz-Hart 10. The Netherlands: The End of an Era and the End of a System: Jelle Visser 11. Belgium: A New Stability in Industrial Relations?: Jacques Vilrokx and Jim Van Leemput 12. Luxembourg: An Island of Stability: Gary Tunsch 13. France: The System of Industrial Relations at a Turning Point?: Janine Goetschy and Patrick Rozenblatt 14. Portugal: Industrial Relations Under Democracy: Jose Barreto 15. Spain: Constructing Institutions and Actors in a Context of Change: Miguel Martinez Lucio with Modesto Escobar, Joaquin Lopez Novo and Victor Perez Diaz 16. Italy: Between Political Exchange and Micro-Corporatism: Anthony Ferner, Richard Hyman and Michael Terry 17. Greece: From State Authoritarianism to Modernization: Nicos D Kritsantonis.
It has recently been suggested that the potentially dynamic and proactive role of employers in industrial relations be recognized (Kochan, McKersie, & Cappelli, 1984). Because incorporating the notion of strategic human resource management appears consistent with that suggestion, it is done here integrating frameworks of competitive strategy and human resource management practices using the rationale of needed employee role behaviors and cost and market conditions. This is then merged with business life-cycles stages creating a contingency framework for understanding the impact of strategic human resource management on industrial relations. This is done also using the rationale of cost and market conditions and needed employee role behaviors. The integrated competitive strategy-human resource management model is extended by inclusion of strategic targets and industry chain. The implications for industrial relations are laced throughout the discussion along with three sets of propositions. Implications for employers, employees, unions, and government are presented in the summary and conclusions. Here, the dynamic and proactive role of employers is placed into perspective.
This report - the fifth edition in a well-established series - aims to increase the visibility of European social dialogue, describe and raise awareness of developments in European industrial relations, and initiate related discussion through its analytical chapters. The 2008 report addresses the main trends in industrial relations in the European Union, European social dialogue and EU labour law as well as the contribution of quality industrial relations to the Lisbon Strategy and wage setting and minimum wages in the European Monetary Union.
Part 1 Theoretical and methodological issues: industrial relations and technical change - the case for an extended perspective, Wolfgang Streeck and Arndt Sorge flexible specialization - miracle or myth?, Richard Hyman comparative research and new technology, Beat Hotz-Hart new technology and social networks at the local and regional level, Reinhard Lund and Jorgen Rasmussen. Part 2 Innovation initiatives: management strategy - towards new forms of regulation?, Serafino Negrelli between Fordism and flexibility?, Stephen Wood new technology in Scotbank, John MacInnes. Part 3 Skills, deskilling and labour market power: labour and monopoly capital, Peter Armstron skills, options and unions, Jon Gulowsen new technology and training, Helen Rainbird. Part 4 Trade union strategies: new technological paradigms, long waves and trade unions, Otto Jacobi technological change and unions, Greg Bamber policy debates over work reorganization in North American unions, Harry Katz the Australian metalworkers' union and industrial change, Stephen Frenkel. Part 5 Technological innovation and workplace relations: information, consultation and the control of new technologies, Robert Price consensual adaptation to new technology - observations on the Finnish case, Pertti Koistinen and Kari Lilja industrial relations and workers' representation at workplace level in France, Sabine Erbes-Seguin bargaining over new technology - a comparison of France and Germany, Michele Tallard.