搜索结果：counterexample

Mathematical reasoning demands two critical, complementary skills: constructing rigorous proofs for true statements and discovering counterexamples that disprove false ones. However, current AI efforts in mathematics focus almost exclusively on proof construction, often neglecting the equally important task of finding counterexamples. In this paper, we address this gap by fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) to reason about and generate counterexamples. We formalize this task as formal counterexample generation, which requires LLMs not only to propose candidate counterexamples but also to produce formal proofs that can be automatically verified in the Lean 4 theorem prover. To enable effective learning, we introduce a symbolic mutation strategy that synthesizes diverse training data by systematically extracting theorems and discarding selected hypotheses, thereby producing diverse counterexample instances. Together with curated datasets, this strategy enables a multi-reward expert iteration framework that substantially enhances both the effectiveness and efficiency of training LLMs for counterexample generation and theorem proving. Experiments on three newly collected benchmark

Signal Temporal Logic (STL) has been widely adopted as a specification language for specifying desirable behaviors of hybrid systems. By monitoring a given STL specification, we can detect the executions that violate it, which are often referred to as counterexamples. In practice, these counterexamples may arise from different causes and thus are relevant to different system defects. To effectively address this, we need a proper criterion for classifying these counterexamples, by which we can comprehend the possible violation patterns and the distributions of these counterexamples with respect to the patterns. In this paper, we propose a classification criterion by using parametric signal temporal logic (PSTL) to represent each class. Due to this formalism, identifying the classes of a counterexample requires finding proper parameter values of PSTL that enable a class to include the counterexample. To improve the efficiency of class identification, we further derive an inclusion relation between different classes, and then propose a binary search-like approach over it that significantly prunes the classes needed to query. We implement a prototype tool and experimentally evaluate it

A minimal counterexample to the Erdős-Gyárfás conjecture is a graph of minimum possible order and size with minimum degree at least 3 that contains no cycle whose length is a power of 2. Markström observed that any such graph must contain an independent set of vertices of degree at least 4 together with a nonempty set of vertices of degree exactly 3. As an immediate consequence, every regular minimal counterexample must be cubic. Building on this structure, two additional consequences are derived. First, every vertex of a minimal counterexample is adjacent to a vertex of degree exactly 3. Second, at least 4/7 of the vertices of any minimal counterexample must have degree exactly 3.

In 2017, Geordie Williamson proved the existence of counterexamples to James's conjecture on the decomposition matrices of symmetric groups and their Hecke algebras. The smallest counterexample detectable by Williamson's method occurs in the symmetric group $\mathfrak{S}_n$ for $n=1 \thinspace 744 \thinspace 860$, in characteristic $p=2237$. Those detected by Williamson remain the only known counterexamples to James's conjecture. In this work, we calculate an explicit new counterexample, occurring in the principal block of the Hecke algebra $\mathscr{H}_{24}$ when $q$ is a primitive fourth root of unity, and give explicit graded decomposition numbers in this case. This is the minimal rank counterexample for $e eq 2$.

Recently, Starr used asymptotic methods to disprove a conjecture by Heim--Neuhauser and Abdesselam about the log-concavity of the D'Arcais polynomials, without giving an explicit counterexample. We refine the asymptotics, to give the necessary estimates on convolutions of $σ_{-1}$, and identify the first counterexample at $λ= 65\,214\,507\,758\,400$. We also consider the asymptotic density of such counterexamples.

Coding agents can fix a failing example without preserving the domain rule that made it fail, so later generations can repeat the same plausible mistake. We present agentic synthesis against counterexample-supplemented sketches, a repository-native method for systems whose governing policy is discovered during implementation. A human starts with a partial, code-shaped sketch, and a coding agent generates the first implementation. When a concrete failure exposes missing or mistaken policy, an operator explicitly approves the corrected behavior and rule. The agent then revises the sketch and repairs or regenerates code and prompt surfaces for that one counterexample. The full archive preserves provenance; a selected regression set gates each revision before the next candidate is revealed; and periodic clean regeneration tests whether the evolved sketch, rather than prompt history or accumulated examples, carries the learned policy. We demonstrate the method with CatSynth, a synthetic browser application and captured coding-agent experiment. In one open-world run with GPT-5.4-mini, 8 of 14 frozen candidate cases became counterexamples. The rebuild controls inherited that promotion sch

Let A = F_q[T] with q a power of an odd prime p, let [n] = T^(q^n) - T, and let rho be the Carlitz module. A monic prime P of A is a c-Wieferich prime (to base 1) if rho_P(1) = 1 mod P^2. Thakur suggested in 2015, on the basis of limited data and of proofs in degrees 2 and 3, that in odd characteristic every c-Wieferich prime has degree divisible by p; the question was restated as open in 2024, and Bamunoba and Bergstrom, after extensive computations, expressed the belief that the statement holds in odd characteristic. We show that it is false: an explicit irreducible c-Wieferich prime of degree 5 over F_{19^3} is exhibited, with 19 not dividing 5. We further give a closed form for the resulting common factor of [5] and M_5: it equals mu(T^q - T) for an explicit quintic mu with coefficients in the prime field F_19, squarefree of degree 5*19^3. Degree 5 is the least possible degree of such a counterexample, and exhaustive computations show that no counterexample exists over the prime fields F_p in a substantial range of degrees and characteristics. Proofs of the completeness statements, and the method by which the example was found, appear in a companion paper.

We exhibit an equigenerated monomial ideal $I\subseteq K[x,y,z,w]$ with $\operatorname{reg}(\overline{I})>\operatorname{reg}(I)$. The ideal $I$ is generated in degree 4 and satisfies $\operatorname{reg}(I)=4$, while its integral closure $\overline{I}$ has a minimal generator of degree 5 and satisfies $\operatorname{reg}(\overline{I})=5$. This gives a counterexample to the polynomial-ring formulation of the Küronya--Pintye conjecture.

We provide a counterexample to the HK-conjecture using the flat manifold odometers constructed by Deeley. Deeley's counterexample uses an odometer built from a flat manifold of dimension 9 and an expansive self-cover. We strengthen this result by showing that for each dimension $d\geq 4$ there is a counterexample to the HK-conjecture built from a flat manifold of dimension $d$. Moreover, we show that this dimension is minimal, as if $d\leq 3$ the HK-conjecture holds for the associated odometer. We also discuss implications for the stable and unstable groupoid of a Smale space.

We show that for every $M,A,n \in \mathbb{N}$ there exists a graph $G$ that does not contain the $(154\times 154)$-grid as a $3$-fat minor and is not $(M,A)$-quasi-isometric to a graph with no $K_n$ minor. This refutes the conjectured coarse grid theorem by Georgakopoulos and Papasoglu and the weak fat minor conjecture of Davies, Hickingbotham, Illingworth, and McCarty. Our construction is a slight modification of the recent counterexample to the weak coarse Menger conjecture from Nguyen, Scott and Seymour. We further modify the construction to show that there are planar graphs that do not have the coarse Erdős-Pósa property.

In this paper we study the essential spectra of the Toeplitz operator on the Hardy space $H^1$. We give a counterexample to show that the Toeplitz operator with symbol is not Fredholm, which gives a counterexample to the conjecture by J.A. Virtanen J A in 2006.

This paper presents a counterexample to the optimality conjecture in convex quantum channel optimization proposed by Coutts et al. The conjecture posits that for nuclear norm minimization problems in quantum channel optimization, the dual certificate of an optimal solution can be uniquely determined via the spectral calculus of the Choi matrix. By constructing a counterexample in 2-dimensional Hilbert spaces, we disprove this conjecture.

We give an example of a function $f$ non-vanishing in the closed bidisk and the affine polynomial minimizing the norm of $1-pf$ in the Hardy space of the bidisk among all affine polynomials $p$. We show that this polynomial vanishes inside the bidisk. This provides a counterexample to the weakest form of a conjecture due to Shanks that has been open since 1980, with applications that arose from digital filter design. This counterexample has a simple form and follows naturally from [7], where the phenomenon of zeros seeping into the unit disk was already observed for similar minimization problems in one variable.

In model checking, when a given model fails to satisfy the desired specification, a typical model checker provides a counterexample that illustrates how the violation occurs. In general, there exist many diverse counterexamples that exhibit distinct violating behaviors, which the user may wish to examine before deciding how to repair the model. Unfortunately, obtaining this information is challenging in existing model checkers since (1) the number of counterexamples may be too large to enumerate one by one, and (2) many of these counterexamples are redundant, in that they describe the same type of violating behavior. In this paper, we propose a technique called counterexample classification. The goal of classification is to partition the space of all counterexamples into a finite set of counterexample classes, each of which describes a distinct type of violating behavior for the given specification. These classes are then presented as a summary of possible violating behaviors in the system, freeing the user from manually having to inspect or analyze numerous counterexamples to extract the same information. We have implemented a prototype of our technique on top of an existing forma

We give a counterexample to the PIA (precise inversion of adjunction) conjecture for minimal log discrepancies. We also give a counterexample to the LSC conjecture for families.

Counterexample generation is an indispensable part of model checking process. In stochastic model checking, counterexample generation is a challenging problem as it is not enough to find a single trace that violates the given property. Instead, a potentially large set of traces with enough probability to violate the property needs to be found. This paper considers counterexample generation for chemical reaction network (CRN) models with potentially infinite state space. A method based on bounded model checking using SMT solving is developed for counterexample generation for CRNs. It intends to find a small set of property violating paths of a given model such that they collectively have a total probability that is above a given threshold. A unique challenge is due to the highly connected state space of CRNs where a counterexample is only a tiny subset of all property violating paths. To address such challenges, this paper presents a number of optimizations including a divide-and-conquer technique to scale up the counterexample generation method for large CRN models. This paper reports results from experiments on a number of infinite-state CRN models.

We present a counterexample to Viterbo's volume-capacity conjecture. This implies, in particular, that in contrast with a well-known conjecture, symplectic capacities do not coincide on the class of convex domains in the classical phase space.

Context: Safety is of paramount importance for cyber-physical systems in domains such as automotive, robotics, and avionics. Formal methods such as model checking are one way to ensure the safety of cyber-physical systems. However, adoption of formal methods in industry is hindered by usability issues, particularly the difficulty of understanding model checking results. Objective: We want to provide an overview of the state of the art for counterexample explanation by investigating the contexts, techniques, and evaluation of research approaches in this field. This overview shall provide an understanding of current and guide future research. Method: To provide this overview, we conducted a systematic literature review. The survey comprises 116 publications that address counterexample explanations for model checking. Results: Most primary studies provide counterexample explanations graphically or as traces, minimize counterexamples to reduce complexity, localize errors in the models expressed in the input formats of model checkers, support linear temporal logic or computation tree logic specifications, and use model checkers of the Symbolic Model Verifier family. Several studies eval

Motivated by the weak gravity conjecture, arXiv:2108.04594 conjectured that in any CFT, the minimal operator dimension at fixed charge is a convex function of the charge. In this letter we construct a counterexample to this convexity conjecture, which is a clockwork-like model with some modifications to make it a weakly-coupled CFT. We also discuss further possible applications of this model and some modified versions of the conjecture which are not ruled out by the counterexample.

Scarparo has constructed counterexamples to Matui's HK-conjecture. These counterexample and other known counterexamples are essentially principal but not principal. In the present paper, a counterexample to the HK-conjecture that is principal is given. Like Scarparo's original counterexample, our counterexample is the transformation groupoid associated to a particular odometer. However, the relevant group is the fundamental group of a flat manifold (and hence is torsion-free) and the associated odometer action is free. The examples discussed here do satisfy the rational version of the HK-conjecture.