Gabapentin as an adjunct to multimodal pain regimens in surgical patients: the GAP placebo-controlled RCT and economic evaluation.

内容摘要

Gabapentin is an anticonvulsant medication with a United Kingdom licence to treat partial seizures and neuropathic pain. It is used off-licence for acute pain and is frequently added to multimodal analgesic regimens after surgery to try and reduce opioid use while controlling pain effectively. To test the hypothesis that gabapentin reduces opioid use after major surgery and speeds up recovery, thereby reducing postoperative hospital length of stay compared to standard multimodal analgesia. The GAP study was a multicentre, blinded, randomised controlled trial in patients aged ≥ 18 years, undergoing cardiac, thoracic or abdominal surgery with an expected postoperative stay of ≥ 2 days in seven National Health Service hospitals. The trial was designed to provide 90% power to detect a difference of 12.5% in the proportion of participants discharged by the median length of stay in each specialty (500 participants/specialty), which was reduced to 80% (340 participants/specialty) due to COVID-19-related recruitment challenges. Participants were randomised 1 : 1 (stratified by surgical specialty) to receive either gabapentin (600 mg before surgery, 300 mg twice daily for 2 days after surgery) or placebo as an adjunct to multimodal pain regimens. Primary outcome was length of stay. Secondary outcomes included acute and chronic (Brief Pain Inventory) pain, total opioid use, adverse health events, health-related quality of life (-EQ-5D-5L, Short Form questionnaire-12 items physical component score and mental component score), resource use; cost-effectiveness (outcome measure quality-adjusted life-years using EQ-5D, five-level version). One thousand one hundred and ninety-six (cardiac 500, thoracic 346, abdominal 350) participants consented and were randomised. Baseline characteristics were well balanced across the two groups: median age: 68 years; male sex 796/1195 (66.4%). Of the participants, 223/1195 (18.7%) did not receive all prescribed medication or received medication out of window. There was no difference in length of stay; median placebo (n = 589): 6.15, gabapentin (n = 595): 5.94 days [hazard ratio for discharge 1.07, 95% confidence interval (0.95 to 1.20), p = 0.26]. Opioid use in-hospital differed between surgical specialties (p = 0.001); in the abdominal specialty, it was significantly lower in the gabapentin group in 4 of the first 5 postoperative days [range -26% (-46% to 0%) to -36% (-52% to -14%)], with no differences in the cardiac specialty nor in the thoracic specialty beyond day 2. During follow-up, opioid use was similar in the two groups across all specialties. Acute pain beyond 24 hours was similar (p ≥ 0.15). The incidence of one or more serious adverse events was placebo: 189/595 (31.7%); gabapentin: 195/599 (32.6%). Health-related quality of life was similar [EQ-5D: mean difference -0.014 (-0.036 to 0.009), Short Form questionnaire-12 items physical component score: -0.87 (-1.71 to -0.04), Short Form questionnaire-12 items mental component score: at 4 weeks 0.74 (-1.71 to 0.42) and 4 months -0.55 (-1.61 to 0.51)]. Differences in costs and quality-adjusted life-years favoured placebo, and gabapentin was not considered cost-effective. GAP study tests the application of gabapentin to major body cavity surgery, but not major non-body cavity surgery, or non-major surgery. The fixed dose and limited duration of gabapentin may reduce applicability to certain populations. Reducing the power to 80% reduced the ability of the trial to detect a beneficial effect of gabapentin. Among patients undergoing major cardiac, thoracic and abdominal surgery, adding gabapentin to multimodal analgesic regimes did not result in a change in length of stay, opiate use in two specialties, acute pain, or health-related quality of life, nor was it cost-effective. Trials to assess the place of gabapentin in major non-body cavity surgery (e.g. joint replacement), or non-major (e.g. day-care) surgery should be considered. This trial is registered as Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN63614165. This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme (NIHR award ref: 15/101/16) and is published in full in Health Technology Assessment; Vol. 30, No. 9. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information. Gabapentin is a medicine used to treat epilepsy and pain caused by damaged nerves. Doctors have recently been using gabapentin to treat pain after an operation, with the intention of reducing the amount of morphine-type drugs (called ‘opioids’) needed while maintaining good pain relief. Doctors want to try to reduce the amount of opioid drugs because they cause side effects (such as dizziness and reduced breathing rate), often delaying discharge from hospital and leading to slower recovery. There is uncertainty about whether adding gabapentin to the usual painkilling drugs will result in good pain relief, with fewer side effects, and therefore faster recovery after surgery. One thousand one hundred and ninety-five adults having major heart, lung or abdominal surgery who were expected to stay in hospital for at least 2 days after their surgery. The participants were given either gabapentin or placebo (the same tablet but with no active drug) just before and twice daily for 2 days after their surgery. We measured how long they stayed in hospital after the surgery, the amount of opioid drugs they used, the amount of pain they had, what their quality of life was and how much they cost the National Health Service. We measured these during their hospital stay and at 4 weeks and 4 months after the surgery. The trial found that there was no difference in the length of hospital stay, the number of adverse health events, or National Health Service costs between people who took gabapentin and those who took the placebo. People who took gabapentin for abdominal and thoracic surgery used fewer opioid-type drugs in-hospital after their surgery – but this did not translate into better pain control or fewer side effects. Therefore, this trial tells us that doctors should stop routinely giving gabapentin to people to reduce their pain after major surgery.